I would have to agree with Amanda, but we are lucky in the NW to have several really wonderful stallions to choose from. I have spent a lot of time with several of the Monarch foals and they have the best personality, plus they're all so beautiful with that head that Monarch throws. Most are put together really well. The horse that I would add to this list is Nancy Rivenburgh's, McCarthy's Jessie James of Rivenburgh.
This decision would be based on which type of mare I had. I don't breed, but if I did, the only type of mares I would own would be structurally correct and pretty. If it were a bigger mare I would go the direction of Monarch as a size refiner and prettiness factor. If I had a more refined mare, I would go the direction of Jesse James, to hopefully get some bigger movement. Although, I have seen several Monarch foals that have big movement, and Monarchs Commotion really passes bigger movement on to his get. The Neighborhood Watch horses are really nice movers that are pretty.
This would be a tough decision, based on all the really neat stallions all over our area. In the end, I have chosen to buy babies. I get to pick from some of the nicest horses in the world. Of course, that is determined by my pocket book at the time I am shopping! Too bad, I haven't won the lottery, because it would sure open up my possibilities.
Some of these breeders in our area have made a science of refining their breeding programs to get the EXACT look they are going for. I know they have spent a lifetime in breeding horses to gain the knowledge they have, to produce the world champion stock, year after year. Some of them are just attaining the perfection they have been striving toward for years. I could never hope to try to breed the perfection that these individuals have attained, so I will just be buying the best foals I can afford from their stock.