The ASPC horse that meets the AMHR height requirements should be allowed to be registered and show under the current rules. That is not to say that is what our (AMHR) National Champions should have to look like.
The next ten years, I foresee the ASPC push being the best marketing ploy AMHA has ever had.
I see it the exact opposite.
I see the mini A size ASPC ponies being VERY popular, both in and out of the AMHA ring. I'm going to list some horses that are currently(or soon to be) AMHR/AMHA/ASPC and this is only a handful of what is out there!
Rhapsodys Latin Tango
D&S Peeping Tom
D&S The Die is Cast
D&S Fast Break
Graham's Ragtime
Grahams Moonlit Tango
Graham's Hula Girl At Heart
Kewpie's Paposa of Arenosa
Buckeye WCF Paposo Mirror Image
Buckeye WCF Classical Jalapeno
Sundance LB Assured
Sundance LB Lexus
Sundance LB Que-Tee
SMO Bolero de Suerte
SMO Adriana de Suerte
AE Destiny's Darling
THR's A Promise Kept
Ten Ls Tigers Legacy
McCarthys Miss Kitty
Michigan's Silver Streak
Michigan's Kiss of Hershey
Michigan’s Blue Plate Special(A size AMHR/ASPC)
Michigan's Little Sharp Image(A size AMHR/ASPC)
Michigan's Struttin' Stuff(A size AMHR/ASPC)
Filipowicz Miss Jo Co(A size AMHR/ASPC)
Filipowicz Folk Lore
*I'm sure I spelled that one wrong*(A size AMHR/ASPC)
There are far more AMHA shetlands then AMHR Hackenys out there, from what I can tell. And I really don't get the "Hackney" issue.
"Hackney" bred anything(Shetlands, minis, road ponies, etc.) are made for DRIVING. And in the AMHR world they will show and WIN in only really three or four classes - Open Pleasure, Park Harness, Roadster and Liberty. So what? Moderns are usually pretty ugly, and would likely not do well in halter. I don't understand how a handful of horses in the Over division in four main classes is going to KILL our breed. Please, someone how this can be so bad? There will still be Country driving and Western.
I see it as evolution of the breed. Some of the A size miniatures are HUGE movers, and drooled over by many. Why is having a HUGE moving B miniature so bad? And I feel if you cross one of those "high stepping Hackneys" to a normal gaited miniature, the cross will allow for a foal with beautiful movement, that is both long and floating in stride but also has some lift. Just like technology, horses change with the times.
As far as I can see, in
any breed, there are "two
types":
The show horse and the pet. Both have a HUGE market. Why can't it be left at that?
My family owns both. We have a back yard, grade QH and a wonderful, quiet Canadian warmblood that we have for riding for our enjoyment. My mother also has a very well bred, expensive Dutch warmblood, which is her Show horse. The Dutch horse is much "more" in all ways, and so he should be - he's bred to be that way!
We can take our Pet horses to local club and open shows and do very well. Would they place as well against the "big boys"? Well no, that why we have a Show horse. LOL To me it is kind of that simple.
By the way, I don't mean to offend anyone with the word "pet"... It was the only would I could think of.
MountainMeadows - Stacy, I have drooled over Prince for years. IMO, he should be the standard of perfection as his conformation is flawless to me. He has a stunning trot and I adore him. That said, you continue to amaze me, not only as a breeder but as a figure head of our breed. To take a horse like Prince and to find areas to improve is wonderful.
To not be barn blind, especially with such a great horse, is a valued quality.
I only wish there were more breeders with such values. Prince is one of my very favorite A size miniatures
But you already know that. I also agree with you with the AMHR x AMHR/ASPC crosses... There are some stunning horses coming from this!
JMS Miniatures, reading your post is sad, as I can see where you are coming from. My reply to you is mixed. I do not believe in tossing someone aside. Yes there are still some driving and performance classes you can always enter, but the halter classes do have a strong classic shetland look to them right now. I like a good horse, no matter the papers(other then AMHR) and as one who wants to cross both AMHR only horses to AMHR/ASPC ones, I am hopeful that the R only B miniature will always have a home. There are some stunning horses out there, not all of them have ASPC papers, and I think that is important to remember.
So just my two cents. Personlally I don'tmind having pet and show horses... I love them all