I need to get Halo a new water bucket, for winter. The one she has now, is great for summer, but it is thin. So I was thinking of getting a rubber black one for her...I can't have an electric one, where she is boarded, so I need to find one that won't freeze as bad. My husband goes and feeds her before work, and can start taking some hot/warm water, to break off any ice that would form, and then I can do the same, with the evening feeding, so I think we will be able, or hope to be able to keep her water from freezing solid. Anyway, do the rubber buckets work good for that? All I have ever seen around here is... rubber, plastic, or the electric. So I'm not sure I really have a choice, but was curious on what others use. I read on the web, that some people have taken of the lid to a ice cooler, and used that, as it is insulated, but I would think the rubber ones would be more durable, plus, being black, would absorb heat from any sun, that would be out, in winter, to help it from freezing. We have to keep the bucket, out from under her shelter. Due to the hose, doesn't reach that far. Not sure what this place does, if the hose freezes.