Also, her dam is listed as a black pinto. Princely Ruler does have a palomino dam, so he very well could be a smokey black but I doubt he is, as of all the foals registered to him, and just quickly skimming the list, I never saw any dillutes listed. So I am still leaning towards black bay, as they can clip out looking black, otherwise, I would say black pinto. The only way to verify would be to test for agouti.