Thank you Marty. I have refreigned from posting my feelings on this as my feelings are like yours... Their may be more to this story than the owners being irresponsible.
As a dog owner, I can honestly say that EVERY dog I have ever had has at one point gotten loose. I have a kennel in a fenced yard. The Kennel has a roof, cement floor and a pad lock on the door. But that doesn't mean that my dog has not on rare occasion bolted past me when I answer the front door and then had a grand ole time roaming. Of course I am always in hot persuit if they do get loose.
And I can honestly say that every dog that I have ever lived next to has at one point gotten loose. If this is the first time that you have ever seen this dog, then chances are that this dog is one that may have just gotten loose.
Now what I would do is ask the humane society if these people are repete offenders. It is those that are the repete offenders that one needs to worry about IMO. If they are not known leash law breakers, then ask these people's neighbors if they see the dog running loose often. If the neighbors say that this dog is always locked up, then you can bet that they feel just aweful that their beloved pet killed your mare.
And remember that most large breed dogs will chase anything smaller than themselves and will kill if given a chance IMO. Everyone has to remember that canines are preditors and it doesn't matter the breed. I have seen all kinds of dog breeds chase minis. Heck, my grandmother's sheltie was one of the worst that I have had to deal with! While the little toy dogs may not kill, they are still just as capable of biting as a large dog. So ALL dogs should be treated as dangerous weapons.
Honestly, I feel sorry for everyone involved!
Marion59, you definately will never get her value back as you can't replace an animal that you love. But hopefully you can at least recover the fair monetary value for her and the loss of her future foals.
And please, if you can find it in your heart to feel a little compasion for the owner of the dog that attacked if you can discover that this was truely an accidental occurance of the dog running loose. I am sure since they were looking for the dog that they love that dog like you loved your mare. Try to give the owners a chance to make things right without having another animal's life lost. If you can find out that this is not normal for the dog being loose, then try to find compasion in your heart for those owners as they honestly are trying to be responsible owners. (If it is normal, then that dog needs to be removed from their care.) And please remember that these people are going to have issues with their homeowner's insurance company now. If they use their homeowners policy to cover this attack, the insurance company will most likely not renew them in the future as they have a dog that is a risk. I know someone who filed a claim for their dog attacking another dog... The person that filed had issues with insurance after that.
Again, so sorry Marrion59 about your mare. It just breaks my heart that you lost her. But at the same time I can find a little compassion for the dog owners just as long as the dog running loose was an honest accident. (If it is a normal thing, then I am would be very angry instead as those owners needlessly caused the death of your mare and I would have no compassion at all as they not only risked their dog's life, but they risk all life as well!)
485845[/snapback]