Jenny -
Glad you found the hay that works for you!
What I wouldn't give to have the same choices available as you do at an affordable price for 37 head!! I miss living in MT and Colorado where we had many choices of hay w/I very reasonable driving distances and delivery and pickup choices!!
The drought and then the over abundance of rain on drought damaged fields mean that the local hay qualities this year are far from good - regardless of the fertilizing and cutting at "optimum times". There were no good times to cut this year and many fields either rotted in the stand as they were too wet to get equipment into or they were burned off to see if the fields would dry out and then the next stand of hay would grow and hopefully be cut. We are woefully short of hay this year - it's the first time I've split my purchasing between 6 local suppliers (usually get ALL my hay from one supplier) in the 10 years we've lived here. Plus getting small bales as needed from two local feed stores (who get theirs from different suppliers)...
Have started adding alfalfa pellets (wet) to the feeding program and may go to feeding alfalfa pellets dry, free choice to some pastures. Also looking at doing the "fodder solutions" - but that's more towards cutting feed than hay. And time consuming - not sure can do that with 40 hour week job... We shall see what we do.