I agree Jill...It is about the individual, HOWEVER it can be said that each breed has its broad tendencies....towards one type of personality or another. Otherwise, there would be no distinct difference of behavior/personality between breeds! Training is one thing, but why go against the basic grain of the animal? I'd rather start with a breed that generally has the personality I want. And go from there.....
But it still comes down to individuals... and false labels. As pit bull fans can attest to.
If I had listened to the "facts" on Borzois... that they are aloof... can never be trusted off leash... not demonstrative... leary of strangers... unable to do anything except lure-coursing.... then
Folli would never have done what she excelled at... certified Therapy Dog along with all her agility and flyball fun...
I took
Folli to a lure-coursing clinic. At 32" she was tall for a bitch - and looked like speed standing still. She was interested when she saw the other dogs running - and eager to catch what they were after... until -
WHAT? - she realized it was a
plastic bag. HUH? A dog who was used to running down coyotes and knocking them over (at our former farm) saw no point in chasing some dumb bag... so when released at the start line she simply sat down. Let those other fools chase some dumb bag...
So much for lure coursing!
Back to the off-leash area - and splash in the river and race in circles and always -
always - come flying when called....
Tag the fox terrier was not actually a terrier, I think :lol: ... more of a Lab or a Golden in a terrier skin. When my friends were practicing for field trials with their Goldens,
Tag would fuss and fret in the truck - so we thought we would start her on the retriever training for fun - as she loved to swim and retrieve
anything. Well - she could have done a trial... she would "honour"... "mark" the bird(s)... send to brush or water... and she had a soft mouth to boot. A couple of the Goldens would not touch actual ducks - Tag thought they were just slightly oily (and heavy) toys...
She also herded the minis - circling and gathering like a Border Collie... she knew
Away to me! and
Come By! and
That'll do!
I miss her...
Fig, on the other hand, thinks water sucks and is best avoided - unless it comes out of a bucket or a hose! Retrieving anything other than toys/balls is patently ridiculous... and the bestest fun you can have is mousing/moling in the loft/flower beds... she is also conveniently deaf when she needs to be - and has a distinct stubborn streak that Tag never had...
Yes - breeds have basic characteristics... but within those parameters the individuals can cover a wide spectrum of personalities and aptitude.