Look at box 1 and 6. Box one is slightly lopped. When ears do not stand straight up and go off to each side they are variations of lopped. See the "V" formation?
Now look at box 6.......those are severely lopped. Anything from 1 to 6 is NOT a tight ear.
I think that what Carol is trying to say is Lop ears has as much to do with placement as position.... If the ears are places further back on the head or out to the side more even at the base they can be considered lop is that right ?Lyn
To me.........any ear........no matter where they are place on the head........that is not straight up, like in the second box and others, (lets say a 90 degree angle( in my opinion is on the verge of loppiness. I am sure that isn't even a word. There are just different degrees!
Okay, I'm biting my tongue until it's bleeding here. Basically: Nope. Nada. Uh-uh. No way. Not correct. Sorry, do not get out of jail free.
My objection here is to using the term "lop ear" to mean anything not straight up, not to anyone's preference for a "tight ear" versus another kind of ear. A lop ear is a very specific condition and it is NOT one found on any normal horse. Now my memory does fail me as to exact medical cause and if it is strictly congenital or can be caused by injury as well, but I
do remember from my 4-H judging days that a lop ear is strictly picture 6 or worse, with no ability to lift the ear up. I think they can sort of swing them forward or back along the sides of the head, but they can't raise them into a normal vertical position. Horses may have one ear this way or both, but it is an actual defect and not a conformational preference issue.
Ears like those seen on horse #1 are perfectly normal and in fact found on most non-hotblooded breeds. My arab Spyderman has ears like that and I find them adorable and friendly (his are slightly more hooky at the tips than the example picture.) You'd better believe though that if he sees something snort-worthy those ears radar forward to point at each other with tips close together! :bgrin #1 is a picture of a relaxed ear posture for him.
I own the book that diagram was taken out of, and Linda Tellington Jones uses that diagram to show some different NORMAL ear shapes/positions and then explains what they can sometimes mean about a horse's personality. Ears that form a V like that (tips further apart than the base) usually indicate a friendly and open personality.
Leia