One is, the other isn't.
AMHR - 209829A SUGAR CREEK PEACHES N CREAM
Sex: MARE Color: CREMELLO
Height: 33.50" Mane & Tail: WHITE
Date Foaled: 4/21/1986 Markings (1): BLUE EYES;
Date Registered: 12/28/2000 Markings (2):
Current Owner: BARBARA M. SMITH Markings (3):
Breeder: MAX NEBERGALL
I can at least tell you why one is and one isn't. I know Peaches N Cream is the dam of Goodasgold. Goodas gold was foaled in 1989, Peaches wasn't registered AMHR until 2000. But if you can get in contact with the owners of Goodasgolds sire and dam he can be registered AMHR as his sire is AMHR too. Did that make sense? He can be registered but will take some tracking down and paperwork but still cheaper than the $260 to take him in with A papers only.