Jump to content


It's official,,,I do NOT like my sons girlfriend

This topic has been archived. This means that you cannot reply to this topic.
14 replies to this topic

#1 Frankie


    I'm a goner

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 7,157 posts

Posted 02 April 2010 - 07:55 PM

My son is 17, has been seeing this girl for about 10 months. I have not said a word or complained to him, have given her more than a chance, but I'm pretty sure I'm done! I just am not a fan of hers.
She doesn't talk and hardly responds to my questions. I usually ask about things she does and school. She'd know the answer to that and maybe talk. She will walk in to the house and not say a word. Last I checked it's still polite to say hello.
Last fall she was at one of his tennis matches, she came up to me and asked how long until they got started, they were warming up. I told her they already started and were in the 4th game. She went to him all upset because I treated her stupid. I was just trying to help her learn the game, she had never seen one before.
Has been bad since. If she's coming over, I get a lecture about not upsetting her. Well, I haven't but I can work on that! smile.gif.
He and I had our date night set, but she cried about wanting to see a movie that night. Uhhhhh, NO!
She was coming over one night, I had planned to fix supper, she didn't like what I had planned and asked if we could get pizza. Asked him, not me. I don't have time to make her happy and couldn't even if I wanted to.
You know our sons really need to listen to there moms, after all, we were THAT girl once and we know!!
I know you can't say anything, and yes I'll keep trying, and yes he is my baby and no girl is good enough,,,but this girl is very trying!!!
Marty, what did you do with girls like this, wait'em out?


Email me



♥ ♥Check out the latest Lil Beginnings Featured Sale Board Ads HERE!

#2 Watcheye


    I gotta get a life...

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,867 posts

Posted 02 April 2010 - 08:53 PM

Oh shes sneaky. I hate the whiny teens.

*edit (sorry I guess that wasnt very helpful at all....just sounds annoying. Hope things go better for you guys. When I was that age as far as I can remember I was friendly to my boyfriends parents. I wanted them to approve of me).

#3 alongman


    I gotta get a life...

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,134 posts

Posted 02 April 2010 - 10:31 PM

AMEN!!!! Some girls are just whiny...........but, wait, so are some boys. smile.gif I put money on you Frankie.......you can take her.
Adam Longman

Longman Miniatures and Shetlands

Home of:
Scott Creek Monarch Afyre (Monarch son)
Blue Ice MTP Guns N Roses (Uno De Mayo breeding)
Grassmere's Jazz Singer (ASPC/AMHR Modern)
Longman's Shadow Spencer (AMHA/AMHR - National Champion All-Star 30-32" Aged Stallion)
Jandt's Our Champion (Boones Little Andy son) - deceased
Plus several other quality stallions

The "Legacy" begins!


#4 White Socks Miniature

White Socks Miniature

    Totally Addicted

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 502 posts

Posted 02 April 2010 - 11:18 PM

all I have to say is....where are her parents?!! Good grief, If I ever talked to someone like that/ didnt talk to them, asked for something different because I didnt like it, invited myself over for a movie night ect, ect. I dont think I would want to come home! Yeesh! There were times where I disliked my parents but I knew they were right and at least behaved well in others presence! Even when I was 5 and 6 I knew better than to tell someone I didnt like something and to eat what was on my plate! It amazes me that some young adults dont have a basic concept of manners and social skills!

#5 Marty


    I just can't help myself :-)

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 24,259 posts

Posted 03 April 2010 - 12:07 AM

My boys are two completely different kids when it comes to girls. Michael was satisfied with his one true love that he had forever, for years since middle school. I adored her, she was so sweet, but she was way too young and I tried to bust that up constantly. I felt worried for her; that when they would ever break up, she would never be able to handle it; that a girl that young should not be that serious. It backfired on me terribly and I learned the more I fought it, the closer they'd become. Michael hated that I was interferring and it kept him constantly upset so I finally backed off for his sake. How horrible that in the end she lost the love of her life to death, not a break up, and to this day has not been able to have another real boyfriend.

Girls don't last too long with Dan. I didn't mean to raise Casanova but apparently I did. I often ask him who is flavor of the month is. He only fell hard for one last year, little Miss Size Zero, the Princess, the Drama Queen......among other things. She was the only girl he ever brought home to meet me, so I knew then, he was serious. She is a model, and was rude, stuck up, full of herself and I saw right through her that she wasn't serious like he was. She couldn't carry on a conversation for nothing; just one word answers, no matter how welcome I tried to make her feel at home, she was stiff as a board. I was dying to make short work of her, however I said nothing, did nothing and bided my time. I had learned my lesson about interferring from Michael. I knew Little Miss Snot Face would move on eventually. And she did. I wanted to chew her up and spit her out. When it was all said and done he asked me why I didn't tell him what I really felt about her and I asked him if it would have done any good and he said probably not.

My advise to you is not to interfere and to ride it out and weather the storm. Sooner or later, she'll screw up and he'll figure it out. That kind of girl gets enough rope and ends up hanging themselves.

I'm no Angel but my child in heaven is. With his hand on my shoulder I can weather any storm.

Michael, My Archangel, My Teen Angel in Heaven
His life was brilliant, His love was pure, He saw an Angel, of that I'm sure...
September 1, 1987- June 10, 2006 Hopelessly devoted to you, then, now and forever
See you in my dreams my love

Welcome to my life grandaughter Lexis Clair Garrison I LOVE YOU SO MUCH!

#6 Littleum


    I gotta get a life...

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPip
  • 1,246 posts

Posted 03 April 2010 - 03:45 AM

Just going to chime in here, because what you're saying struck a chord with me.

Well, she's 17. Chances are she'll be gone eventually. And chances are, she's exactly what you say she is.


I met my husband when I was 18 and he was 19. We've been together 13 years.

I never really got along with his family. It's not that we didn't get along, it's that well, frankly, we communicate differently. Even 13 years later, I feel like we grapple with the fact we seem to express things in exact opposite ways. Square peg, round hole. Just an example, but my family shows affection through teasing. His family is the EXACT opposite. So for the first four years, his parents thought I was awful- they just didn't TELL anyone this. They just grinned and bore it, figuring I was a passing thing. And then the floodgates opened 4 years later on my husband with zero warning. His parents never actually spoke with me about it. Ever.

If you think there's a chance this girl might be a long term fixture, don't let these feelings fester. If it's a real failure to communicate and her heart is in the right place, she'll want to address the issues. Bringing them to surface after years of "good natured tolerance" and "I'm only telling you now because I realize she's not going anywhere" will only create incredible feelings of resentment and betrayal in her, and will probably damage your relationship with her (and quite possibly your son) in a very real and very permanent way. Give her a chance to show her stripes.
~ Rocking M 3 T Vanilla Ice ~ 35" palomino pinto gelding
~ RFM Thunderhawk's Raindance ~ 34" bay mare
~ Little America's Terrific Rainman ~ itsy bitsy bay colt!

Paying much too much attention to Miniature-dom since 1991.

"The nice thing about memories is the good ones are stronger and linger longer than the bad and we sure have some incredibly good memories." - EverythingButWings

#7 Sonya


    I'm a goner

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 6,196 posts

Posted 03 April 2010 - 04:25 AM

Well girls at 17 are often shy and do not know well how to communicate, especially with parents of their boyfriends. You just have to ride it out, chances are the relationship won't last long, but then again it could. One thing I will say...you do not want to raise a momma's boy who needs his apron strings cut. I married one and if I hadn't cut those strings right away, the marriage would not have lasted. Yes, it's great that a son respects/loves his mother (it will ultimately determine the kind of husband he will be when he grows up) but you don't want those strings so tight that it will shut out every other person he comes in contact with. If this girl is not good for him, he will have to learn on his own....if she is what he wants, you will have to accept it....and remember just because she is not good for you doesn't necessarily mean she is not good for him. Your complaints are more of how she treats you and not how she treats him....so keep that in mind. Does she sound whiney? Yes, but she is 17 and girls these days are not like they were 20 years ago.

My words come from someone who was NOT liked by the in-laws at first...ultimately because they felt I was taking away their son...they were angry that he wanted to be with me instead of his family. I remember it was my birthday, our first year of marriage and we made plans to go on a two day canoe trip, well they were angry because on Sundays we usually went to thier house (and no they had nothing planned for me). He was actually going to cancel the trip to please his Mother....cancel his wife's birthday, I had to nip this in the but quickly or we would not have made it. Now, things are totally different and they love me to pieces, when they call they normally talk to me for 15 mins and him for 5....have I changed....no....they did.

I say just let it ride out....as long as she is not treating him badly, it's really not of concern to you. I know that sounds harsh but he has to do these things on his own.

Animals are such agreeable friends - they ask no questions, they pass no criticisms.

What makes a river so restful to people is that it doesn't have any doubt - it is sure to get where it is going, and it doesn't want to go anywhere else.

#8 CharlesFamily


    Totally Addicted

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPip
  • 532 posts

Posted 03 April 2010 - 06:25 AM

I'd like to say give her the benefit of the doubt and hopefully she'll come around, but that didn't work in my family. When my brother was 18 he began dating this girl who acted EXACTLY like you are describing. I was already married and out of the house, but at family get-togethers she wouldn't talk, hide out in another room, etc. We were told she was just "backward" and "shy" and our family was just too overwhelming for her.

I won't even go into what she put my family through for 6 long years. It's too unbelievable. Unfortunately, in your situation, there is nothing you can do. The more you push and try to point out what she is doing, the more your son will turn to her and push you away. That's what happened to us.

Just tough it out, try and kill her with kindness! Hopefully she'll end up being the one who looks like the fool in the end and hopefully he comes to his senses!

Good luck!
The Charles Family: Todd, Barbara, Olivia and Madalyn
Cross Creek Stable

Happy home to my barnful of boys:
Irish Hills Toys in the Attic "Toy" - 2008 Multi-National Top 10 Halter Gelding and all-around fun guy!
Irish Hills LKF Junior Jinx "Jinx" - 2004 AMHA/AMHR Buckskin Gelding RIP Jinx 03.24.2004 - 10.08.2011
Rebel Jet "Jet" - QH gelding, former barrel horse and resident pasture potato

My girls were born with broken hearts - support Congenital Heart Defect Research!

#9 Frankie


    I'm a goner

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 7,157 posts

Posted 03 April 2010 - 06:40 AM

I do appreciate your thoughts, some I hadn't considered, none I felt harsh.
I do have an older son, he will be 33 next month, don't tell anyone though, talking of my 17 year old makes me a little younger! smile.gif He never dated one like this. All were out going, and polite, but like was mentioned, that was several years ago and yes, the girls were different.
I have considered a lot with this one. She is caught between parents who are divorced who have stuck her in the middle. Live with me I'll give you all this, type stuck in the middle.
And I am not putting them all in the same group, but she is the "classic" cheerleader type girl, and I think we all had one of those at our school.
I have looked at the positives. She is always dressed nice, is a straight A student, involved with other school functions and clubs and does well.
It's hard to say how she treats him, I'm sure she is different when not around me. This is where I don't like the cell phones. Back in the day, they had to call the house, sometimes me answering, and getting to say, hi, how are you and having a small conversation, but now, she just calls his phone.
I can make more of an effort I guess, and like I said, I haven't complained to him, do not want to push him in any direction, and I will try and consider what you guys have said.
But if the wind blows right again, and she says one more time it smells like horses out side,,,I'll take Adams advice!


Email me



#10 Sunny


    Someone just shoot me!

  • Member
  • PipPipPipPipPipPip
  • 2,157 posts

Posted 03 April 2010 - 09:27 AM

I'm sorry to hear you're going through this. My daughter just turned 14 and the dating world is on the near horizon. I hope she never brings home a boy I disapprove of as much as you do this girl your son is seeing!

Not having faced your situation yet myself, I'm probably talking through my hat, but this is what I would do. First, I would talk with your son and, gently but firmly, express your opinion about this girl and the reasons for it. It probably won't change things or make him dump her, but at least the seed would be planted. From what I've read in your various posts about him, he sounds like a very sensible young man who has a lot of respect for his mom. At least he might think about what you said. Second, I would have a talk with that girl. It's your home that she is visiting, and you deserve to be treated respectfully. My guess is that she hasn't had the best upbringing and it's not your job to do it now, but I don't think it's inappropriate for you to tell her that "in this house, we greet each other when we arrive" or "in this house, we eat what's put on the table", or whatever. (With any luck, she might dislike it enough to never come around again! LOL Except that your son might go with her....) Over the years my daughter's friends have come for dinner or whatever and, if they weren't in the habit of saying please and thank you at home, they developed it at my house!

My daughter (14, looks 16) met a 15 (looks 18) year old boy at a karate clinic last Friday night, and then saw him again the next day at the tournament. They spent a lot of time together through the day and exchanged emails and MSN's. I asked her Sensei (teacher) about him and his opinion of the boy was very high, so I felt comfortable enough. In the car on the way home, I laid out some ground rules about dating so she would know my expectations ahead of time. No big surprises there. I know they chatted online a number of times through the week and then, lo and behold, she asked me if he could come to her karate class on Thursday evening. So he did, and I had a chance to meet him and talk with him quite a bit. What an absolute treat this young man is! Very polite, strong handshake, talks easily, hardworking, industrious, etc. Everything a girl's mom could ask for! :-) I hope this is a sign of thngs to come!

JUDY NEVILLE (formerly Bakker)
Mount Sterling, OHIO (Area 2)